My team is here to serve. Our unique backgrounds, training and experience have prepared us well to help meet your insurance needs. Additionally, as residents of your community, we understand how important it is to be there for you - our trusted friends and neighbors. Together, we're building strong partnerships that help everyone succeed.

  • :
  • English
  • :
  • (855) 375-1246
a group of women posing for a photo in the snow
No Photo Available

Amelia Moe

Non-Licensed Staff
No Photo Available

Amy Anderson

woman smiling for the camera

Angela Logan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I have been working for Tammy Belisle / American Family Insurance since the Fall of 2006. I rotate between the three office on a normal basis which keeps me on my toes. I also have been involved with the Chamber of Commerce and really have enjoyed meeting new people. I currently live in the Saint Croix Falls area and love hiking all the trails and attending the local events.
a portrait of Brianna

Brianna Schaar

Customer Service Representative
woman with long hair

Gina Thiel

Customer Service Representative
I have been with Tammy's agency since February 2018. I am Karolyn's assistant, servicing commercial and farm ranch policies. When I am not working I enjoy spending time on my hobby farm with my husband Tyler, our son Henry, daughter Jonna and all of our critters!
No Photo Available

Grace Siera

Non-Licensed Staff
woman with long hair

Jessica McCoy

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I also need to add a Bio for Jessica: I have been a Sales Representative with the Tammy Belisle Agency since 2024. Being a Wisconsin resident my entire life I, like any good cheesehead, love a Friday night fish fry with a side of squeaky cheese curds. If I'm not at work you can catch me with my nose in a book, belting out 90's country songs in my kitchen, or exploring new places around WI and MN with my husband and our four kids.
woman smiling for the camera

Jolene Sullivan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I began my insurance career with Tammy in 2002 and returned to work for her in the fall of 2019. I have worked in the insurance industry for over 20 years. I work in the Hudson office. I live in River Falls with my husband, Jim, and my twin boys, James and John, and our 3 cats, Smokey, Bandit, and Jake. I enjoy Kayaking, traveling, and binge-watching TV.
No Photo Available

Kandi Olson

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Karolyn Witthoft

Office Manager
I have been with the Tammy Belisle Agency since January of 2001, mostly working out of the New Richmond office. I live in Clear Lake WI with my husband Leigh. When I am not in the office, I spend most of my time with Leigh, my two daughters Meghann and Rachel, and my son Mitch. I enjoy quilting, reading, baking cookies, and refinishing antiques in my free time. If we have not met yet, make sure to stop in my office and say hi next time you're in. I look forward to meeting you!
woman with long hair

Katelyn Kozak

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Sara Marlett

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I am a sales representative at Tammy’s Agency and have been here since 2015. I rotate between the Saint Croix Falls, New Richmond, and Hudson offices. I live in Clear Lake with my other half Jason, and our kids Nathan, Nick, Kiley, and David. In my spare time I enjoy hanging out with my family and reading.
woman smiling for the camera

Stephanie Formo

Office Manager
I started working for Tammy June of 2016. I rotate between all three offices. When I am not working I like to spend time with my family and friends. I also like to go camping, most outdoor activities, painting, and reading.

Teresa Hach

Sales Specialist - All Lines
I have been with Tammy's agency since 2012 working in sales. I enjoy the fast paced, never the same day twice aspect of insurance. When I am not working I enjoy spending time with my husband Tony, and our 2 daughters Katelyn and Payson on our hobby farm in Saint Croix Falls.
No Photo Available

Amelia Moe

Non-Licensed Staff
No Photo Available

Amy Anderson

woman smiling for the camera

Angela Logan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I have been working for Tammy Belisle / American Family Insurance since the Fall of 2006. I rotate between the three office on a normal basis which keeps me on my toes. I also have been involved with the Chamber of Commerce and really have enjoyed meeting new people. I currently live in the Saint Croix Falls area and love hiking all the trails and attending the local events.
a portrait of Brianna

Brianna Schaar

Customer Service Representative
woman with long hair

Gina Thiel

Customer Service Representative
I have been with Tammy's agency since February 2018. I am Karolyn's assistant, servicing commercial and farm ranch policies. When I am not working I enjoy spending time on my hobby farm with my husband Tyler, our son Henry, daughter Jonna and all of our critters!
No Photo Available

Grace Siera

Non-Licensed Staff
woman with long hair

Jessica McCoy

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I also need to add a Bio for Jessica: I have been a Sales Representative with the Tammy Belisle Agency since 2024. Being a Wisconsin resident my entire life I, like any good cheesehead, love a Friday night fish fry with a side of squeaky cheese curds. If I'm not at work you can catch me with my nose in a book, belting out 90's country songs in my kitchen, or exploring new places around WI and MN with my husband and our four kids.
woman smiling for the camera

Jolene Sullivan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I began my insurance career with Tammy in 2002 and returned to work for her in the fall of 2019. I have worked in the insurance industry for over 20 years. I work in the Hudson office. I live in River Falls with my husband, Jim, and my twin boys, James and John, and our 3 cats, Smokey, Bandit, and Jake. I enjoy Kayaking, traveling, and binge-watching TV.
No Photo Available

Kandi Olson

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Karolyn Witthoft

Office Manager
I have been with the Tammy Belisle Agency since January of 2001, mostly working out of the New Richmond office. I live in Clear Lake WI with my husband Leigh. When I am not in the office, I spend most of my time with Leigh, my two daughters Meghann and Rachel, and my son Mitch. I enjoy quilting, reading, baking cookies, and refinishing antiques in my free time. If we have not met yet, make sure to stop in my office and say hi next time you're in. I look forward to meeting you!
woman with long hair

Katelyn Kozak

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Sara Marlett

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I am a sales representative at Tammy’s Agency and have been here since 2015. I rotate between the Saint Croix Falls, New Richmond, and Hudson offices. I live in Clear Lake with my other half Jason, and our kids Nathan, Nick, Kiley, and David. In my spare time I enjoy hanging out with my family and reading.
woman smiling for the camera

Stephanie Formo

Office Manager
I started working for Tammy June of 2016. I rotate between all three offices. When I am not working I like to spend time with my family and friends. I also like to go camping, most outdoor activities, painting, and reading.

Teresa Hach

Sales Specialist - All Lines
I have been with Tammy's agency since 2012 working in sales. I enjoy the fast paced, never the same day twice aspect of insurance. When I am not working I enjoy spending time with my husband Tony, and our 2 daughters Katelyn and Payson on our hobby farm in Saint Croix Falls.
No Photo Available

Amelia Moe

Non-Licensed Staff
No Photo Available

Amy Anderson

woman smiling for the camera

Angela Logan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I have been working for Tammy Belisle / American Family Insurance since the Fall of 2006. I rotate between the three office on a normal basis which keeps me on my toes. I also have been involved with the Chamber of Commerce and really have enjoyed meeting new people. I currently live in the Saint Croix Falls area and love hiking all the trails and attending the local events.
a portrait of Brianna

Brianna Schaar

Customer Service Representative
woman with long hair

Gina Thiel

Customer Service Representative
I have been with Tammy's agency since February 2018. I am Karolyn's assistant, servicing commercial and farm ranch policies. When I am not working I enjoy spending time on my hobby farm with my husband Tyler, our son Henry, daughter Jonna and all of our critters!
No Photo Available

Grace Siera

Non-Licensed Staff
woman with long hair

Jessica McCoy

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I also need to add a Bio for Jessica: I have been a Sales Representative with the Tammy Belisle Agency since 2024. Being a Wisconsin resident my entire life I, like any good cheesehead, love a Friday night fish fry with a side of squeaky cheese curds. If I'm not at work you can catch me with my nose in a book, belting out 90's country songs in my kitchen, or exploring new places around WI and MN with my husband and our four kids.
woman smiling for the camera

Jolene Sullivan

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I began my insurance career with Tammy in 2002 and returned to work for her in the fall of 2019. I have worked in the insurance industry for over 20 years. I work in the Hudson office. I live in River Falls with my husband, Jim, and my twin boys, James and John, and our 3 cats, Smokey, Bandit, and Jake. I enjoy Kayaking, traveling, and binge-watching TV.
No Photo Available

Kandi Olson

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Karolyn Witthoft

Office Manager
I have been with the Tammy Belisle Agency since January of 2001, mostly working out of the New Richmond office. I live in Clear Lake WI with my husband Leigh. When I am not in the office, I spend most of my time with Leigh, my two daughters Meghann and Rachel, and my son Mitch. I enjoy quilting, reading, baking cookies, and refinishing antiques in my free time. If we have not met yet, make sure to stop in my office and say hi next time you're in. I look forward to meeting you!
woman with long hair

Katelyn Kozak

Customer Service Representative
woman smiling for the camera

Sara Marlett

Sales Specialist - Personal Lines
I am a sales representative at Tammy’s Agency and have been here since 2015. I rotate between the Saint Croix Falls, New Richmond, and Hudson offices. I live in Clear Lake with my other half Jason, and our kids Nathan, Nick, Kiley, and David. In my spare time I enjoy hanging out with my family and reading.
woman smiling for the camera

Stephanie Formo

Office Manager
I started working for Tammy June of 2016. I rotate between all three offices. When I am not working I like to spend time with my family and friends. I also like to go camping, most outdoor activities, painting, and reading.

Teresa Hach

Sales Specialist - All Lines
I have been with Tammy's agency since 2012 working in sales. I enjoy the fast paced, never the same day twice aspect of insurance. When I am not working I enjoy spending time with my husband Tony, and our 2 daughters Katelyn and Payson on our hobby farm in Saint Croix Falls.